How to Check Cooling Tower Performance

Introduction

Whether you operate a large industrial water cooling tower or an HVAC water cooling tower system, regular performance evaluation is essential for reliability, efficiency, and longevity. This article explains how to check cooling tower performance, including key metrics, testing methods, calculators, and practical tips. Both water cooled tower and closed loop cooling tower systems are covered, with relevant tables and images to guide your inspection process. Examples reference best-practice solutions from manufacturers such as Mach Cooling (https://www.machcooling.com/).

---

1. Why Monitoring Cooling Tower Performance Matters

A down-rated cooling tower wastes energy and water, increases operating costs, and may reduce the life of associated equipment. Performance checks help ensure:

• Efficient heat rejection

• Optimal cooling tower water supply usage

• Reduced risk of microbiological growth and corrosion

• Compliance with operational targets

Routine performance checks also support predictive maintenance and avoid catastrophic failures.

---

2. Core Indicators of Cooling Tower Performance

2.1 Thermal Efficiency (Approach & Range)

Performance is typically measured using range and approach:

• Range = Hot water inlet temperature − Cold water outlet temperature

• Approach = Cold water outlet temperature − Ambient wet bulb temperature

Low approach values indicate better performance.

---

2.2 Water Usage Metrics

Good performance ensures controlled water consumption. Important metrics include:

• Evaporation loss rate

• Blowdown rate

• Total cooling tower water testing results

---

2.3 Air Flow and Drift

Air movement significantly impacts heat transfer:

• Fan efficiency

• Drift eliminators

• Air flow uniformity

Poor airflow reduces thermal performance and wastes energy.

---

3. Essential Measurements for Performance Testing

3.1 Thermometer Locations

Measure temperatures at:

• Hot water inlet (return from load)

• Cold water outlet (to load)

• Ambient location near tower inlet

Accurate instrumentation is key to reliable results.

---

3.2 Wet Bulb Temperature Measurement

Wet bulb temperature reflects actual cooling potential of ambient air. It should be taken close to the tower inlet, shielded from direct sunlight and moisture.

---

3.3 Flow Rate Measurements

Water flow rate (m³/h or GPM) must be known for correct heat balance calculations. Use validated flow meters for accuracy.

---

4. Step-by-Step Performance Assessment

4.1 Step 1: Thermal Performance Calculation

Use the following formulas:

Parameter	Formula
Range	(T_{hot} - T_{cold})
Approach	(T_{cold} - T_{wet,bulb})

Example:

Value	Measurement
Hot water inlet	40°C
Cold water outlet	30°C
Ambient wet bulb	25°C

• Range = 40 − 30 = 10°C

• Approach = 30 − 25 = 5°C

Smaller approach indicates better performance.

---

4.2 Step 2: Heat Load Check

Confirm heat load matches design:

[
Q = 4.186 \times W \times (T_{hot} - T_{cold})
]

Where
(Q) = heat rejected (kW)
(W) = water flow (L/s)

Compare against design values from manufacturer data.

---

4.3 Step 3: Evaluate Water Quality

Cooling tower water testing should include:

• pH

• Conductivity

• Hardness

• Total dissolved solids (TDS)

Poor water quality lowers efficiency, accelerates corrosion, and increases fouling.

---

4.4 Step 4: Air Flow Inspection

Check:

• Fan RPM and power draw

• Condition of blades

• Drift eliminator integrity

Obstructions in air path or damaged fans can significantly reduce performance.

---

5. Performance Metrics and Targets

5.1 Typical Industry Targets

Metric	Acceptable Range
Range	5–12°C
Approach	<7°C for most systems
Cooling water return flow	Within 5% of design
Water conductivity	Per treatment standards

Note: Targets vary by climate, system age, and installed capacity.

---

5.2 Closed Loop Cooling Tower Considerations

Closed loop cooling tower systems have separate spray and process circuits. Performance checks should ensure:

• Spray water heat rejection matches design

• Process loop temperatures are stable

• Water quality in both circuits is acceptable

---

6. Tools for Effective Performance Checks

6.1 Digital Thermometers and Wet Bulb Instruments

Accurate temperature measurements support reliable data.

---

6.2 Flow Meters and Sensors

Flow measurement enables correct heat balance calculations.

---

6.3 Water Testing Kits

Portable kits can measure pH, conductivity, and hardness on site.

---

7. Typical Inspection Checklist

7.1 Daily/Weekly Checks

• Basin water level

• Fan operation

• Water temperature readings

• Visual signs of scale/fouling

---

7.2 Monthly/Quarterly Checks

• Full cooling tower water testing

• Blowdown rate versus target

• Drift eliminator condition

---

7.3 Annual Inspection

• Structural integrity

• Mechanical and electrical reviews

• Performance trend analysis

---

8. Case Example: Evaluating a Cooling Tower

8.1 Given Data

Parameter	Value
Water flow	1000 m³/h
Hot water inlet	42°C
Cold water outlet	32°C
Ambient wet bulb	26°C

---

8.2 Calculations

• Range = 42 – 32 = 10°C

• Approach = 32 – 26 = 6°C

These values indicate reasonable performance but should be compared with design specifications from the cooling tower manufacturer.

---

Conclusion

Checking cooling tower performance is essential for maintaining the efficiency and reliability of any water cooling tower system. By focusing on thermal performance, water and air flow characteristics, and consistent cooling tower water testing, operators can identify issues early and optimize operations.

Regular performance checks support:

• Lower operational costs

• Improved water cooling tower water supply usage

• Reduced environmental impact

• Long service life for both water cooled tower and closed loop cooling tower systems

Utilizing comprehensive guides and products from industry leaders like Mach Cooling (https://www.machcooling.com/) makes performance evaluation structured and effective.

---

If you’d like, I can provide printable checklists, Excel calculators, or a PDF field guide for performance inspections!